Surdo hliník vs. dřevo

[JoyJr]

Zdravim, potřeboval bych radu. Jakej je zvukovej rozdíl mezi hliníkovým a dřevěným surdem. Rozhoduju se mezi těmahle dvouma. http://kytary.cz/meinl-su18-l-ab-m/HN125190/ a http://kytary.cz/meinl-su18-l/HN125189/ Díky!

[Nero]

Nejlépe uděláš, když si je oboje vyzkoušíš.

Info:

What should your surdo be made of ?

Surdos are commonly sold with bodies of aluminium, steel or wood.

Steel surdos are cheap and hardy, but they are heavy and they can have a dull tone. They are also quite hard to knock back into shape if dented.

Wood surdos sound wonderful if they have hide heads and they can be very light and easy to carry. With plastic heads they sound like any other surdo drum but give less volume, and they are fragile. Where a metal surdo will dent, but remain perfectly playable, a wooden one will crack and become unuseable. Because of this, people with wooden surdos often end up having to buy heavy and expensive hard cases to protect their drums, making them bulky and heavy. However if you are looking for one surdo for stage work, the beautiful mellow sound of a wooden surdo with a natural leather head is worth going for.

Aluminium surdos combine the durability of a metal surdo with the light weight of a wooden one. They are easy to knock back into shape and repair and you can expect decades of use from them. In Rio these surdos are designed to be played with hide heads and they sound beautifully mellow like this. (Vegetarians can compromise with napa; artificial leather). But in North Eastern Brazil and outside Brazil altogether, most big percussion ensembles use surdos with plastic heads.

[Medák]

Obecně je hliník hodně suchý, oproti dřevu méně melodický, což ale nemusí být na škodu. Vyzkoušej, uvidíš.

[Jazzman]

Podle mě jsou zvukové rozdíly malé, za to odolnost hliníku na vlhkost i náraz výrazně větší. Surdo je buben, který se nosí, převáží, hraje se na něj venku.......Mám hliník.